Author: Sabina Paglialunga

  • NASH Pathway to Approval – Light at the End of the Tunnel

    Not long ago, there was very little regulatory guidance or recommendations regarding a pathway for nonalcoholic steatohepatitis (NASH) drug approval. NASH is a chronic hepatic disease that can lead to cirrhosis, liver failure and need for transplant, and currently there is no FDA-approved treatment for NASH, creating a large unmet need for patients. On the bright side, there is a bountiful pipeline of drugs in development for this disease. Many investigational products are being developed under an accelerated process that uses surrogate endpoints such as tissue biopsy results for initial approval followed by clinical outcome measures for full approval. However, it was not until recently that the acceptable endpoint definitions and consensus on patient I/E criteria were described. Academic and industry led partnerships have spearheaded discussion forums for all stakeholders to advance the regulatory science of NASH. To this end, hepatic focused research societies such as the Liver Forum, AASLD and EASL have developed a set of study design considerations for NASH trials. In addition, both the FDA and EMA released draft guidance documents within the past year, providing a clear pathway to approval.

    Society Insight

    The Liver Forum helped define key terminology for NASH clinical trial endpoints such as NASH resolution. While previous Phase IIb trials may have used more lenient criteria, it is now widely accepted that NASH resolution is defined as a histological ballooning injury store of 0, inflammation score of 0-1 and steatosis score of 0-3 according the NAFLD Activity Score (NAS).  More recently, meeting proceedings from a joint AASLD/EASL Workshop addressed standards for reporting results from NAFLD clinical trials. They suggest reporting absolute change in primary and secondary endpoints rather than percent change only as well as absolute number and proportion of patients that improved, remained stable, or worsened on treatment and placebo. Another key recommendation is to report the performance of noninvasive imaging and soluble biomarkers in relation to histological biopsy results. This information is needed to eventually replace the liver biopsy with a simpler, noninvasive measurement.

    Regulatory Authority Recommendations

    The FDA released two sets of draft guidance for NASH drug development, distinguishing between non-cirrhotic (fibrosis stages 1-3) and cirrhotic (stage 4) disease states.  Recommended early phase endpoints for non-cirrhotic NASH include imaging changes in AST and ALT, imaging measures of liver stiffness or hepatic fat content or disease-specific biomarkers such as de novo lipogenesis fractional rates. Participant inclusion criteria for these early studies can be based on histological diagnosis of NASH or a combination of biochemical criteria and/or imaging evidence of steatosis in addition to known risk factors for NASH. For late phase studies, clinical endpoints include NASH resolution with no worsening of fibrosis and/or ≥1 stage improvement in the fibrosis stage with no worsening of NASH for pre-cirrhotic NASH indication. Cirrhotic NASH endpoints for Phase III studies are ≥1 stage improvement in the fibrosis stage with no worsening of NASH, rates of hepatic decompensation events and MELD progression. Hard endpoints are captured as all-cause mortality, liver transplant and hospitalization rates.

    In late 2018, the EMA issued considerations for drugs to treat NASH in a reflection paper. In contrast to the FDA guidance, the European authority takes a more judicious view by recommending co-primary endpoints of both NASH resolution and fibrosis improvement for anti-inflammatory drugs; and 2-stage improvement in fibrosis for anti-fibrotic therapies.

    Hurdles to Overcome

    There are still many challenges to face for NASH drug development. High screen failure rates of 40-60% are not uncommon for clinical trials with biopsy requirements. Steps to mitigate screen fails include robust patient pre-screening with non-invasive techniques such as FibroScan or opting for imaging-based inclusion criteria over biopsy-proven NASH (for Phase IIa studies).

    Another issue to contend with is the large placebo response for histological endpoints. A meta-analysis by Han et al. found that one quarter of patients given placebo had an improvement in NAS by ≥2 points, and improvements in fibrosis scores of approximately 20%. Spontaneous disease regression can contribute to the observed placebo response. External influencing factors may include diet, exercise, and modest amounts of alcohol consumption during the trial. A lead-in period prior to the baseline biopsy may minimize the placebo effect. Meanwhile, 2-stage fibrosis improvement would drastically reduce the placebo response and could be considered as a secondary endpoint to negate false negative studies.

    While the liver biopsy remains the reference standard for disease diagnosis, the ultimate goal is to have a noninvasive soluble biomarker to stage the disease, akin to HbA1c for diabetes and cholesterol for cardiovascular disease.  Biomarkers of inflammatory cytokines, apoptosis (cytokeratin 18) and fibrotic factors show promise, however more validation is required.

    The Road Ahead

    Despite these challenges, there is a light at the end of the tunnel! Clarification of agency expectations and unified definitions has certainly helped to foster the influx of NASH drugs in development. However, the true test will come from a review of upcoming new drug applications. The first approval for a NASH treatment is anticipated by the end of the year, with more to follow suit in 2020.

  • Celerion Celebrates 50th Anniversary of First Clinical Trial

    Celerion is proud to celebrate the 50th anniversary of the first clinical trial, conducted at our facilities in Lincoln, Nebraska. The company, originally called Harris Laboratories, conducted its first clinical research study in 1969, becoming one of the first organizations to offer an independent clinical research testing environment.

  • Backing the Biosimilar Boon

    Biological therapies such as peptides, enzymes and antibodies have changed the face of medicine, providing crucial treatment for a number of devastating inflammatory, endocrine and oncological diseases. However, these drugs often come with a hefty price tag due to the complicated nature of manufacturing biological products which are derived from living systems. In an effort to reduce drug prices, especially among biologicals, the Biologics Price Competition and Innovation Act was passed in 2010, creating a regulatory framework for biosimilar drugs to advance on to the market.

    Biosimilars are not an exact copy but are similar to the originally approved biological product. While innovator products must demonstrate pharmacokinetic (PK), dose finding, efficacy, safety and clinical benefit/risk for approval; a biosimilar product follows an abbreviated pathway and must demonstrate equivalent PK, toxicity, similarity, and no clinical change compared to the innovator. With this framework, the goal is to introduce cost-effective alternatives to innovator biological drugs that can help improve patient access to these treatments.

    The Biosimilar Model:
    Robust, vigorous analytical characterization, justification of cell lines, examination of post-translation products, and preclinical studies are emphasized in the biosimilar paradigm. Most biosimilar programs only require one Phase I or III study, reducing cohort sizes and study time from traditional drug approval processes. Immunogenicity data must be collected in patients, however this can be descriptive in nature and is not required to be powered.

    In lieu of a comparative efficacy study, pharmacodynamic (PD) biomarkers related to the mechanism of action can be evaluated as a study outcome. For example, picture a biosimilar product like recombinant insulin binding to a cell receptor to initiate a chain of signaling events. PD biomarkers such as glucose concentrations from these early events of the signaling cascade tend to be more sensitive, while late PD biomarkers like HbA1c are related to clinical outcome yet tend to have lower sensitivity. Therefore, early PD biomarkers are recommended as they are apt to illustrate how a drug behaves and can be applied to simulate PK/PD dose response. Both PK and PD biomarkers are required to be within margins to show equivalency, for the FDA these margins are 80-125%. When no good PD biomarker is available for an indication, clinical endpoints should be the same as the innovator product.

    The FDA’s Action Plan:
    While the EU has benefited from biosimilars for close to 15 years, with 45 approved products and marked reductions in drug prices [1], the US has been slow to embrace this technology. To date, 19 biosimilars have been approved in the US, however 7 products are still not on the market mainly due to patent litigation [1]. In an effort to cut-red tape, increase drug competition and reduce prices for patients, the FDA released their Biosimilar Action Plan in June 2018. This plan outlines their four-pronged approach to expedite biosimilar product development through; increasing efficiency in the approval process, clarifying regulatory guidance, providing educational support for patients and prescribers, and supporting market competition. Progress towards these goals is evident through 60 biosimilar development programs, a newly released final guidance for interchangeability, and plans to license biosimilar and interchangeable insulin products.

    Optimizing Biosimilar Product Development:
    The following study design recommendations are aimed to optimize biosimilar programs when planning for multiple authorities or indications, or for interchangeability designation.

    Multiple Jurisdictions – Consider a 3-way crossover study with US and EU innovator and reference product to establish bridging for various markets.

    Extrapolation – Consider running the study in the most homogenous patient group, this will improve sensitivity. Once approved for one indication, approval can be extrapolated to all other approved indications with justification based on totality of evidence.

    Interchangeability– Refers to pharmacists switching between products without the consent of the prescriber. In the EU, interchangeability of a product is dictated by member states. Elsewhere, Australia has recently granted interchangeability designation for adalimumab biosimilar products [2] . In the US, interchangeability of a biosimilar should be demonstrated in a randomized two-arm (switching vs non-switching) clinical study with a reference product lead-in period. In a crossover design, the switching arm should have at least 2 or more product switches. One major challenge with interchangeability study design is that many antibody biosimilars have long half-lives and which would require a long cross-over study. However, the added statistical power of the cross-over design may well be worth the long study duration. In addition, during such trials, it is important to closely monitor for safety and adverse immune responses. Alternative approach is an integrated study design to demonstrate no clinically meaningful difference between reference and the biosimilar product and evaluate the impact of switching.

    Turn-key Solutions for Biosimilar Programs:
    As a global leader in analytical and clinical studies for biological drug development, Celerion provides turn-key solutions for a number of biosimilar programs.

    • Adalimumab – Anti-TNFα biological for the treatment of arthritis, plaque psoriasis, ankylosing spondylitis, Crohn’s disease, and ulcerative colitis
    • Rituximab – CD20 antagonist for autoimmune diseases
    • Teripartide – Recombinant human parathyroid hormone for osteoporosis
    • Ustekinumba– IL-12/23 inhibitors for psoriasis
    • See our full list of validated bioanalytical assays at www.celerion.com/assays

    Conclusion:
    Altogether, biosimilars are primed to make a significant impact on access to vital medicines worldwide. Currently, of the marketed biosimilar products available in the US the cost for these products is an estimated 17-57% less than the originator price. With new, efficient tools to support biosimilar development, the FDA aims to see even more meaningful impact on drug prices.

    References:
    1. Sarpatwari A, Barenie R, Curfman G, Darrow JJ, Kesselheim AS. The US Biosimilar Market: Stunted Growth and Possible Reforms. Clin Pharmacol Ther. 2019;105(1):92-100.
    2. JULY 2018 PBAC MEETING –POSITIVE RECOMMENDATION. https://www.pbs.gov.au/industry/listing/elements/pbac-meetings/pbac-outcomes/2018-07/positive-recommendations-07-2018.pdf. Accessed 2 April 2019.